Wednesday, September 12, 2007

Rhetoric (NYT articles)

http://www.nytimes.com/2007/09/09/travel/09prac.html?_r=1&8dpc&oref=slogin
This article is using a little bit of logos persuasion, as it is using logical to make a statement—that might not be the main thing—the internet being a bad influence for such things, as hotel and room reservations. Logical because, it is an idea our society has been developing throughout the past years. And, it is logical, to say, that if reservations online turn out what they’re not, it is rather preferable to do direct reservations.

http://www.nytimes.com/2007/09/12/technology/techspecial/12threat.html?ref=technology
Is talking about computer programs and systems not being infected by hackers or viruses; rather, by themselves.

It might be difficult to convince the mob that supposed ‘clean’ programs are the ones who are damaging the computer. Speaker uses pretty much the persuasion of logos, because emotion and character doesn’t deal at all with discoveries in our technology. But then again, why would proving something based on research be logical? It might not belong to any of these forms of persuasion at all.

http://www.nytimes.com/2007/09/12/opinion/12wed3.html
In this article, the speaker is using a bit of each persuasion, mostly logos (explains that people are doing wrong at avoiding such law, because children need proper education to they can exceed later on in life), and ethos (because the speaker is expressing that the lack of education goes against his beliefs and ideas).

http://www.nytimes.com/2007/09/12/arts/television/12goss.html?ref=arts
This article doesn’t use persuasion, as the speaker is only trying to inform, rather than state an opinion. Talks about this new series called “Gossip Girl” on Warner Channel, and how much popularity it is gaining.

Perhaps, wants to convince readers to watch the series, but there is no evidence whether the speaker has seen the series or likes them.

http://travel.nytimes.com/2007/09/09/travel/09weekend.html?ref=travel
Though the speaker is not trying to persuade someone about something, he/she is giving them advice on how to plan their weekend depending on where they live, if they are interested on Salsa.

Indirectly, though, he persuading a little bit, telling people to go to have some fun and dancing at salsa clubs. Therefore, he is using the persuasion of pathos and ethos, as within his emotion he likes salsa, and within his character he enjoys it.

In overall conclusion, I was able to understand that most of the articles within newspapers are not rhetoric. Though some articles are based on personal opinion, a newspaper is all about informing a general public, about whichever topic the article is dealing with.

So, it might use persuasion, but not as intense. The newspaper is not seeking to express their opinion on a certain topic, because, it is true, what could it serve them? Or their readers? They are rather trying to convince their audience to make their own minds about what they inform about; because, as the speakers, they must be aware that the people reading this, each has its own ideas or beliefs.

Tuesday, September 11, 2007

Amphion, Linus and Marsyas, Pgs. 154-155

Those who plot the destruction of others often fall themselves.
-Phaedrus (Thrace of Macedonia)

Then revenge is some sort of force, that shall bounce back again on whoever caused it. Revenge is usually seen within fables, or other short stories that explain a lesson—myths, too. In Amphion, Antiope, the mother, along wit her two childs, Amphion and Zethus, plot vengeance on Lycus, arrogant king of Thebes, and his wife, Dirce, because they were the ones who had treated Antiope with cruelty in the first place. Then, in the myth Linus, Hercules kills his music tutor, Linus, in revenge, because of what he had told his pupil—first. Finally, the God Apollo punishes to death some brave-like man named Marsyas, because of him being swollen with pride and challenging the God initially, in the myth Marsyas.

This above, all show acts of revenge. But, based on our culture today, is revenge valid? Is it somewhat fare? It is true, you are somehow levelling yourself with someone else. You are not actually doing it because you’re mean and you want to, it is rather because that person did something bad to you first.

But which action was first? It’s not like we count or remember who started whichever conflict. And this way, the only thing revenge will do is extend this argument till forever and ever, just because the two sides think they are levelling with one another.

And, if revenge is considered good, then so would other negative traits such as greed, viewed as some sort of taking care of personal stuff, and wrath, seen as an alarming warning towards other people could be considered good too…yet only good to the person planting this action.

Quote taken from:
www.worldofquotes.com/topic/Revenge/1/index.html

Monday, September 10, 2007

Chp XV: Perseus, Medusa, Atlas, and Andromeda


The three myths I read for today have everything to do with one another, as they belong to the same chapter and focus on the same characters; Perseus.

I was able to compare Perseus with Gilgamesh himself in various ways. First, we can say both characters are one in a kind. Say, Perseus was born as a God, but then sent away with his mother by his grandpa, as he had been told by some oracle something about this newborn killing him. Then Gilgamesh, is part human part Gods, therefore superior in a way than other humans; he is the creator as well, of the city of Uruk, and someone who none would dare fight.

With the characteristics they have, either Perseus or Gilgamesh have their own unique way or perceiving the world, and others. Gilgamesh, believing he is superior, demands respect and shows seriousness towards others. Perseus, he is not quite used to being loved, and is unwelcome wherever he goes, cause of what prophecies have said. He is seeking to gain respect and therefore is strong and always willing to do his best, to defeat.

Visions affect both the epic and the myths dramatically. Perseus might have never killed the Medusa nor met Andromeda, if his grandfather had never believed what the oracle told him. When Gilgamesh told his mother about some vision he had had, and his mother’s analysis is false, Gilgamesh without knowing it, beliefs his mother, and therefore is never prepared for the arrival of his equal—Enkidu. Were this visions to be taken differently by the characters, the text would have a different result. Perseus might have belonged along with his family of Gods, and Gilgamesh would’ve prepared some type of surprise attack for Enkidu, meaning that Enkidu might have end up killed before he and Gilgamesh became friends.

Sunday, September 9, 2007

Prometheus and Pandora, Apollo and Daphne, and Pyramus and Thisbe

In a relationship, what does the male represent, and what does the female? Does a female always represent the same things in overall cultures, or is it rather different depending on each couple?

How has this idea of sexism changed over periods of time? At least, how much has it changed since the supposed existence of Roman myths and Gods?

Recall the myth Prometheus and Pandora. We can tell whoever told this story, is representing the women as rather foolish and troublemaker, mischievous; as, supposedly, it was a women who spilled the jar with Epimetheus secrets, all flaws that today inhabit human beings and societies.

But, the representation of the sexes, might be affected too, on what type of a relationship the male and the female are sharing.

If a relationship is pure, filled with love and passion, then the female, as to the male, might be something perfect, everything he ever wished for. The female then, might perceive the male as a courageous loving being; this type of relationship, in which the couple loves each other strongly no matter what, can be seen on the myth of Pryamus and Thisbe. They love each other so much they ignore their flaws.

Then this kind of relationship was meant to happen. Lovely. It felt right so they liked each other, and not that anyone is obligating them to love each other, they just do. Will the relationship be different if the couple happened not by pure love and desire, but by one solid cause? If we focussed on the myth of Apollo and Daphne, then we shall prove how different the relationship can indeed be. Daphne, while Apollo is in love, tends to feel obligated if she were to love Apollo.

If there is a relationship filled with love, there might be a similar type of relationship, nonetheless having more to do with friendship. This, we can see it through Gilgamesh’s and Enkidu’s companionship. Here, the two people within the relationship are not so deeply focused on each other, they tend to be together and together they shall defeat and defend themselves. Love, is more of loving your lover, then friendship is more like loving your alliance—both of yourselves.

Thursday, September 6, 2007

Juno and her Rivals, Callisto (Chp. IV), Monsters (Chp. XVI

I’ve heard a bunch of times, around the media, and in church mainly, that our God up there is there to take care of us, to forgive us no matter how many times we screw up; so we can say he is someone good, some pleasant father that is always willing to give us a second chance, because he knows, and we know, some of us, that we can do it right.

But, when I read Juno and her Rivals, I started doubting whether all Gods, in all religions are as good as our God. Cause, in the myth, Juno is not what we could call patient.

So I thought the behaviour of our Gods towards us has varied, throughout time, in all religions. At the time in which Gilgamesh lived, if he did, it is easy to notice the Gods behaved different, mostly like Juno. They probably were this way, because the Gods, were much more linked to humans in some way or other. They lived among them sometimes, and gave them advice and punished them; they had more human-like characteristics.

As the myth Callisto shows, jealousy was a human-characteristic that Juno had; she was certainly jealous of the beautifulness of one of the nymphs, Callisto. As jealous and powerful as she was, she converted the poor nymph into a big brown bear, removing her attractive human characteristics.

How can we be sure if our God, today, is even human? He/she doesn’t definitely share human characteristic, cause it is rather hard to find a perfect human being.

But then, later on, no matter how angry might have Juno or her husband Jupiter be, humans and other mortals like to contradict them, just sometimes; at doing this, unlike modernity, they are fully aware of what dangerous consequences might rebellion bring.

In Monsters, this is similar to Gilgamesh as well, as Gilgamesh, part, human therefore part immortal, liked to disobey the Gods, when going into the Cedar Forest, when insulting Ishtar; Enkidu disobeyed hell, when breaking all the rules and doing sorts of things he wasn’t supposed to do. Practically, no matter how important might the Gods have been once to us, we, as humans, as imperfections, think evil and…ignore the Gods sometimes.

Wednesday, September 5, 2007

Responding to Calvin's Story

At first I wasn’t sure on how I should start this entry, as so much questions and ideas based on the text came to mind. Calvin’s story it’s…really confusing, yet exclusive, and similar to Ishmael, as it makes you think a lot.

Made me think of such things as are Qfwfq and (k)yK humans?


They aren’t exactly humans, nor do they belong to any specie living on this Earth. They are even vaguely alive, as they were…just there staring at creation itself, and gambling about what was supposed to happen.

If there was nothing to know, nothing to learn from or not anything for there to be that might have made Qfwfq think, then why did he know all that? How was he able to predict everything and mention random facts about future—future in their case—such as Mesopotamia vs. Aryans, and who shall wins from Arsenal and Real Madrid?

This story includes many of the topics we have until now learned in class. For a start, it talks about creation, like if it were just any other myth, explaining its own beliefs, on where we come from, on how and when was the world created. I wondered as well, what type of knowledge wasQfwfq using, when he talked and gambled about the future.

In simulation to Gilgamesh, Qfwfq and (k)yK could be said to be the Gilgamesh and the Enkidu of the story. Though they seemed to have known each other forever (unlike the characters in the epic), they act as true companions, and they are okay with each other’s company. Both pairs of buddies have some dilemma they shall study and face, in Gilgamesh and Enkidu’s case, to exceed in whichever threatening adventure they embark. The dilemma Qfwfq and (k)yK face is practically the creation of the world, of everything, to their eyes.

Neither of the four had an idea of how much effect their stories have for the future, for the civilization today. What might have Qfwfq thought if he were to know all of his bets we know today by fact, what might have Gilgamesh thought if today his story is the first written piece in the world…

Sunday, September 2, 2007

Entry 8 (Whole epic)

The influence of Gods and their actions within the epic are massive, as the epic would have a totally different significance and ending if somehow the Gods didn’t act the way they did.

For a start, Anu the God of the city, obeying the people’s pleads, creates Enkidu, supposedly the one who was to equalize Gilgamesh and defeat him. Were Anu to be some kind of ignorant selfish God, Enkidu wouldn’t have been created, never meeting Gilgamesh, and never would have they later become the invincible duo.

Then Shamash comes in. Gilgamesh’s mother prays to him for the safety and security of her son, during the journey he is about to embark with his now new companion, Enkidu. Shamash agrees, and grants safety as promised to Gilgamesh. It is most possible that without Shamash protection and company, Gilgamesh might have loosened in self-confidence and moral strength.

When Gilgamesh neglects to Ishtar’s—Goddess—love, she is enraged, sending Gilgamesh and his city the Bull of Heaven, as a curse and punishment. This new challenges, influences Gilgamesh and Enkidu’s relationship, making them more united, more invincible.

The Chief Gods decided, in the heavens that either Gilgamesh or Enkidu should die. Later, Enkidu falls gravely sick and slowly, dies, fact that made Gilgamesh embark on the terrible journey, to find immortality, his only wish left to live for.

What if the Gods had chosen Gilgamesh to die instead of Enkidu? Would Enkidu have become ruler of Uruk…would he want to kill himself too for depression and disgust…?

Finally, we can consider Gilgamesh himself as a God too, as he is 2 parts God 1 part Human. As the main character in the Epic, he mostly makes his own decisions and as their leader, other characters shall follow him. He is the one who decides to go into the Cedar Forest, he, with such selfish attitude at the beginning, makes the people of the city want another leader so they could get rid of him. If Gilgamesh had accepted, someway, Ishtar’s love, his friendly relationship wit Enkidu might have never grew strong nor eternal.