Wednesday, November 14, 2007

Analects Books 4-6

Goodness in our Lives

4.25 The master said, “Virtue is never solitary; it always has neighbours.”

As this book (4) itself talks a lot about “Goodness”, I guess it could be considered a neighbour. I wanted to focus on “Goodness” and will give various examples of it, and try to explain what it is to be good, according to the Analects.

4.1 The Master said, “…If one does not choose to dwell among those who are Good, how will one obtain wisdom?”

The Master is connecting wisdom, that the people among the Good have it. To be Good though, doesn’t necessarily mean that you are smart, as there can be smart people that are mean towards others. But maybe this term—wisdom—is used differently, that it does not exactly means to be smart. I guess having wisdom in “Confucism” means rather, to know how to be good, and to act and respond in a “good” manner amongst all aspects of life.

4.2 The Master said, “Without Goodness, one cannot remain constant in adversity and cannot enjoy enduring happiness.”

It is good to be able to dwell within adversity, because these people that are not “good”, means they tend to dislike other kinds of people, prejudicing them. It is therefore good to respect whichever kind of people, as we are all equal, no matter their ethnicity, or beliefs, or religion.

4.3 The Master said, “Only one who is Good is able to truly love others or despise others.”

When you are good, you can love the ones who are good as you. You only have this right of “despising” other people when you are Good, because if you are not good and you hate someone, you are hating wrongfully, since you are the one doing wrong in the first place.

4.6 The Master said, “…Is there a person who can, for the space of a single day, simply devote his efforts to Goodness? I have never met anyone whose strength was insufficient for this task. Perhaps such a person exists, but I have yet to meet him.”

People have the capacity to be Good, to dedicate their lives towards Goodness, but some can’t even for a day. It’s not that they can’t, rather that they don’t try. The Master believes that he will find someday, this person that, as most, has the capacity, but also the willingness to be Good.

The Masters make us realize how truly important is it being Good. How it influences in all aspects of our lives, our relationships with other peoples, our souls. How our life will change for the better if we’re good.

Tuesday, November 13, 2007

Anaclets, Books 1-3

Virtue, 100%

Unlike the Bible, Virtue plays a mayor role within the Analects. It’s their way—the Masters’ way, to control of everything, various areas including the family, the goodness, music, and even the politics, in conclusion, virtue being the perfect way to lead someone throughout their lives.

I say it’s different from the Bible, this use of Virtue, because we could say that most of the characters within the Books we read, were controlled—their lives were—by God. It was God who decided what they should or shouldn’t do, and when disobeying they were punished. Characters such as Abraham and Moses, and Saul, were considered ‘good’ people because they obeyed God.

So far, in the Ana there hasn’t been any mention of punishment. I was able to find, though, that the punishment we shall give it ourselves, it’s like a punishment of morality, of us realizing what we’ve done wrong.

2.15 The Master said: “If you Learn without thinking about what you have learned, you will be lost. If you think without learning, however, you will fall into danger.”

The citation above leads us into another argument; we are allowed to do what we want to do, and we will not be severely punished—rather by ourselves. We can think and not learn, or learn and not think, and our punishment will be the “not-learning”. Plus, it is not literally that we will fall into danger, it says rather that we are approaching a dangerous and naïve stage. The Masters want the humans (or believers of Confucius), to be more responsible, to be able to make our own choices and know that we are responsible for whatever happens.


----------------------------------------------------------

2.21
“…Thus, in being a filial son and good brother, one is already taking part in government. What need is there, then, to speak of ‘participating in government’?”

Now, this citation focuses more into politics. ____ describes joining the government as an act of being good with your family, therefore connecting politics and family, as a very similar thing, as the same action. We can say here again, that Virtue is their way (the Masters’) to educate and teach others, and be better; you’d be involved in the government as long as you’re a good brother, or loyal son. Politics doesn’t mean having power, or having the ability to ruin a country. Rather, it’s when a community is running accordingly thanks to Virtue, for it’s people to perform ‘Goodness’, and be loyal family members.

The Analects Books 1-3 show how Virtue is employed by the Masters to give the correct teaching; how they believe that it is the correct way for people to be ‘good’. It is mentioned, at the beginning of Book 1, of how Virtue and morals are as important as the knowledge of fact.

Wednesday, November 7, 2007

Job Chp. 38-End

Then the Lord answered Job, out of the whirlwind, and said,
2 Who
is
this that darketh counsel by words without knowledge?
3 Gird up now thy loins like a man; for I will demand of thee, and answered thou me.
4 Where wast thou when I laid the foundations of the earth? declare, if thou hast understanding.

We have talked so much about God—or Gods, when in Greek myths. It confused me, when we saw at the beginning of Genesis, that there were two different Gods.

Then I doubt who is this God, that takes place in Job. Yes, he is definitely different because (as I mentioned in my other Job entry) he lets himself be manipulated, in some way, by Satan. I guess the Gods of Genesis wouldn’t have done that, because, at least, one of them realizes the wickedness of men, and therefore bringing in the flood.

Knowing of this ‘wickedness’, why is it that this God lets a ‘wicked human’ take such an important decision as torturing someone?

Then again, in the citation above, this God himself is talking about he being the creator of Genesis.

Similar to the Greek Myths, the God within Job takes a little bit of ‘human character’ within these last pages. It happens after Job has said it all, about wanting to die, after he speaks to his friends, when God wants Job to forgive him. We could say, taking into consideration the amount of space that God’s words take in this piece of the Bible, that he is being somehow intense and annoying on Job. He doesn’t want to admit that he was somehow cruel on Job, and though perhaps, some things that Job ‘cursed’ about were valid, God whatsoever doesn’t want to admit he was unfair; that for a second, he made a mistake, like a human. He is almighty and powerful after all; he was the creator, and therefore has the right to be stubborn and decide what he did or didn’t—even if it is kind of a lie.

So God’s attitudes and actions within this part of Job, show us how God can make mistakes as well, and how—similar to humans—he doesn’t want to admit it, is ashamed.

Tuesday, November 6, 2007

Job Chp. 11-37

Sometimes, we let ourselves be controlled by our friends, or either trusting them. And this is not bad; it is good for us as people to learn to trust others, therefore making us more ‘socially-active’ beings.

Now, friendship and advice plays an important role in this piece of Job. After Satan is able to torture Job, and Job is grieved and angry, his friends come, and give him advice.

Though practically they all say the same thing—that Job was punished because of being wicked—they might be wrong. Personally, I believe it was God the one being ‘wicked’, for once. There was no reason why Job deserved punishment.

So, these friends are blaming Job himself for the happenings, but Job decides not to trust them;

Then Job answered and said,

2 I have heard many such things: miserable comforters are ye all.
3 Shall vain words have an end? or what emboldneth thee that thou answerest?
(From Book 16)

Though they are our friends, we are the ones who decide whether we want them to control us, whether should be believe in the advice they give us. Job decided not to ‘follow’ them, and I guess it’s okay. What’s actually not right, is the way in which he responds, rather than saying thank you, for they gave their advice at least.

He recalls they are speaking ‘vain words’, therefore, in a foolish and perhaps dishonest way.

Yet, he is saying something very truthful; perhaps their advice was more blame than helpful. Though Job wasn’t very much aware of what he did, he had done it, and it was now in the past, unable to be changed. His friends should have at least focused a little less on this inaccessible past, and actually try to give advice to what Job might do now.

So, we could say none of the two ‘sides’ were completely right. Job did wrong in answering, as the friends did wrong in helping. We must understand that as imperfect beings, everything we have and give shall be imperfect as well (Friendship). We must also try to be patient, have friends, but have a little bit of self-control and decision—since it’s your life.

Thursday, November 1, 2007

Job Chp. 1-10

Favor and Manipulation

So far manipulation in the Bible has been crucial; it could be said God manipulated Moses, and at least told Abraham and Noah what to do, and what not to do. He as well manipulated the Pharaoh, indirectly, by hardening his heart, which indeed affected the decisions the Pharaoh took.

If not manipulation, the characters ask God for their help always, as David, when defeating Goliath, and Moses, too, when trying to control the Israelite mob. So there is definitely a permanent bonding between God and humans, and favours asked within—something intentionally, other times not.

Characters ask God favours for something they desire to do, but never do they manage to control them.

Now, in Job, there is a strange manipulation, because Satan is able to control God. Or at least he is asking too much, and I say it can be manipulation, cause God almighty could say no, to what Satan is asking, and it is probable, because of what he asks will affect gravely another person.

God whatsoever agrees and accepts. I wonder why God might listen to whatever Satan says. Why hadn’t he done it before? If God is manipulated, maybe he shall be considered a human too—

We can’t forget, though, that there is not greater than God. We have discussed that the Greek gods and goddesses are similar to humans, as they tend to make mistakes and fall in love and suffer. But what about this God? We can’t be sure whether he can be similar to humans, and, who would manipulate him anyway? How is it possible for Satan to manipulate someone so superior?

It is for pure jealously Satan wants for Job to suffer, to make God realize that though he was the 'strongest', and perhaps God's favorite, he shall not be the best. But—making reference to the Greek myths—power can be harmful sometimes, and power is what Satan is gaining, power stolen indirectly from Job. For a moment, when Job is depressed and thinks about dying and 'cursing the day' Satan becomes the new Job, for a moment, superior, cause it was God that listened to him and agreed with waht he had in mind.

It is “unfair” for God to favour one side; after all, he was the one who created humans, who’d later on divide and reproduce into “sides”. How could God favour one and not the other?

Tuesday, October 30, 2007

Samuel II Chp. 1-12

Nobody's Perfect

The Samuel chapters read today prove that NOBODY’S PERFECT.

Not even the great leaders of the past, of long ago, it shows.

David was able to defend Israel, and untie it. He was concerned about every man on his “side”, and treated his enemies with respect, aware that they could be as powerful as he was, never underestimating them. He (this is linked to my other blog of Samuel) showed tons of courage for such a small boy, when he defeated Goliath, act that gained him fame among Israel.

It is definitely difficult to have sufficient courage to be able to approach a warrior 5 times bigger than you. But David trusted God, and tried it out, and succeeded, first hard step that led him to Glory.

He didn’t take advantage of his power; never treated anyone condescendingly and respected them all. It seemed David was good alright.

And this is where Love, one of the strongest of feelings interferes, prevents. During a battle, David positions one of his warriors in a dangerous spot, so he can get killed, intentionally. All this he did because he desired the woman that man was married to, so much.

Later on he realized what he had done, and he was for once upset with himself, realizing he had sinned.

We have to remember, though, David was human and therefore he was “allowed” to make mistakes. True, not as grave, but what else can be expected? After all, he was human, and humans aren’t perfect. No matter when or where we live or lived, we tend to sin—and not only once.

Sources

I searched of each related topic on www.wikipedia.org, and then scrolled down to take a look at the secondary soucres, from where wikipedia had taken out the information.

In my persuasive speech, I'm talking about Racism and Discrimination, recalling much the events ocurring during WW2, the biggest scene of injustice and racism seen in history, the Holocaust.

Holocaust:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holocaust#See_also

Provided us with other sources of similar information having to do with the Holocaust, probably used to provide the information for them in the 1st place.

Nazi:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nazi#External_links
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nazi#References_and_notes

Some of the sources used by Wikipedia (in the web):
http://www.britannica.com/eb/article-9055014/National-Socialism
Though, this source, too, can't be considered secondary, because as Wikipedia it is an Encyclopedia, that bases its information from other secondary sources. I wasn't able to find the sources that Britannica used.
http://www.holocaust.com.au/glossary.htm

Antisemitism:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antisemitism#External_links
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antisemitism#References

Adolf Hitler:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adolf_hitler#External_links
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adolf_hitler#References

Mostly all secondary sources used were biographies, either on paper, or online.

Ghetto:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ghetto#References
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ghetto#See_also
Similar topics, they might have provided each other with information.

*I noticed not all references come from the web, there are some which are based on books or magazines as well. Yet, most are secondary sources, cause not only is it hard to find original primary documents in the web, but secondary sources explain their contents much better.