Thursday, September 27, 2007

Fallacies (NYT Op-Ed)

Idaho’s Original Same-Sex Scandal

WHEN Senator Larry Craig faced the television cameras here last week and denied three times that he was gay, many Idahoans were reminded of a much older sex scandal, one that rocked the state’s political capital 52 years ago and made national headlines.
There are few in Idaho who have not heard of Boise’s gay sex scandal of 1955. And across the country, a generation of gay men grew up haunted by the publicity it engendered.

Fallacy by Tradition; the population of Idaho recalled an event from the past, and applied it to what happened just now.

Larry Craig was a 10-year-old Idaho farm boy when the scandal broke, and he was a student at the University of Idaho in 1966 when John Gerassi’s book “The Boys of Boise” revived the controversy. Decades later, the wounds inflicted by it remain raw: a lawsuit involving news reports that looked back at some of the allegations made during the now-distant scandal went to the Idaho Supreme Court in 2000.

On Halloween night in 1955, when the scandal broke, Boise was a sleepy little city of fewer than 40,000 residents. It was the kind of town where everyone seemed to know everyone else, or at least worked with, or was related to, someone who did. So when three men were arrested for having sex with teenage boys, the story generated screaming headlines — above the nameplate — in the city’s evening newspaper.

The arrested men were no strangers to Boiseans. They were the salesman at the leading men’s clothier, the shoeshine man on Main Street and a warehouseman from a local family. Boise’s newspaper, The Idaho Statesman, responded to the arrests with a series of editorials demanding that prosecutors, the police and the community take action. The newspaper printed lines like “Crush the monster” and “This mess must be removed.”

Genetic Fallacy: The authority in Idaho says that being gay is completely wrong, cause they believe against it; they really don’t have solid evidence to prove why it might be wrong.

“It did not seem possible that this community ever harbored homosexuals to ravage our youth,” the paper’s editorial page declared. The newspaper helped to ignite a witch hunt, in which many in Boise sought to rid the community of all of its gay men.

More arrests followed: a lawyer, a teacher, and most sensational, the vice president of the city’s largest bank. The roundup snared consenting adults as well as men who dallied with teens.

By the time snow fell, scores of men had been questioned. Sixteen were charged, including one who was hauled back from San Francisco, where he had fled when the scandal broke.
Of the 16 men who were formally charged, only one, the one who denied it all, who fought the case through a brutal trial, beat the charges. His steadfast denials, coupled with questions about the evidence against him, persuaded the jury to let him go.
The lesson of the 1955 scandal was clear: sexual misconduct — or even the mere perception that one is gay — could ruin a man’s reputation. But steadfast, straight-in-the-eye denial just might get him off the hook.


Appeal to Popularity: the life of a man was ruined, if they were gay, because the people and society didn’t approve of it; they disliked it, therefore, leaving aside people who’d be gay.

Today, Boise is the urban center of a metro area with a half-million residents. Boise’s gay life, compared with that in San Francisco or even Portland, Ore., is quiet, but it is active enough to support a community center, a drag court, three gay bars and a monthly newspaper. The city even elected and re-elected a lesbian to the State Legislature in 2004 and 2006.

But a half-century after the 1955 scandal, Larry Craig’s change of heart about his guilty plea for disorderly conduct in a Minneapolis restroom recalls the similar lament of the most prominent of the accused men, Boise’s bank vice president. “I pleaded guilty on the advice of my attorney because he stated with all the publicity and stink that had been raised, there was nothing else I could do,” the man later said. “I knew my life was ruined anyway and threw myself on the mercy of the court.”

The Golden Fleece, Medea, and Aristaues, the Bee-Keeper

These three myths talk about different characters who had to fight and overpass certain obstacles and challenges to gain what they were seeking for.

The Golden Fleece was a chariot-like thing obtained by Athamas, given by Mercury. In it, her son travelled to the kingdom of Colchis, and as appreciation handed the Golden Fleece to the king, who immediately secured it, with a dragon.

Then came Jason, who’d soon be the ruler of part of another kingdom nearby. He went to claim his land to his uncle, as the other part of the kingdom belonged to Jason’s father. But Pilas—the uncle—wasn’t willing to give his nephew the throne without gifts or rewards. So he said he’d give his throne, as soon as he’d bring the Golden Fleece from Colchis, which had supposedly stolen.

Brave as he was, Jason embarked along with many other courageous Greeks, and arrived. Medea, the daughter of the king was asked to help by Jason. In reward, he said, he’d marry her.

Jason married Medea eventually. As any good potion-maker, it would be easy for the couple to mostly gained what they wanted. And, as indirect as it may seem, the way the reward was for Medea, in this myth, was vengeance. She felt she’d been good in all her overall makings, and she only affected people only positively. Of what she hated of Pilas, she didn’t make the right potion, and therefore killed Pilas.

The reward Medea had to pay for killing, was remaining alone, as Jason left her for another women.

Then, the third myth I read, Aristaeus the Bee-Keeper, shows the journey he made to ask Proteus, an old prophet why was it that his bees had died. Having the patience, to do all the sacrifices and offerings to the gods that the prophet made him do, he came back home and found his bees back alive.

Similar to what it is gaining a price today. You are not raised to a higher position if you don’t work hard, as you won’t get an award if you do your best in school. Life, we are given to live, but not are we given the riches we’d like to have and live with; on the other hand, we have to fight for them and show we really want them—by making a good effort.

Wednesday, September 26, 2007

About the Ones who Misbehaved and recieved their Punishments

You did better, as long as you followed whatever the Gods said, in Ancient Greece. If one immortal dared think that he/she might be able to defeat the gods, then he/she was mostly doomed.

Minerva—known mostly by the name Athena—was the God of wisdom, truly, as she’d win any contests standing on her way to desire. It was said that she had a great talent for both the usual skills for men, but had she a great talent too, for weaving.

Then one day, Arachne, a maiden, decides to come in competition with the Goddess. She says that she’d like to compete against Minerva, and feels that is just ready to beat a Goddess.

We could say, then, that Minerva was patient, as she wasn’t as keen to beat the mortal, to show off her divinity. Rather, she disguised herself of an old lady, and went to talk to the maiden, saying that what she had done, at trying to compete against Minerva, was lack of respect and loyalty; that if maybe, the Goddess was merciful, she shall live. But Arachne paid no attention whatsoever.

At the end, though, no matter whether if we win or loose, there is nothing we can do, because….our competition was a Goddess, after all. She, yet dressed as the old lady suddenly stops weaving and did not kill her, but rather made her live as a spider, so she, most importantly could remember the memory—day in which she decided to misbehave.

The myth of Niobe tells about a queen, who believed that she was more powerful than the gods. So, every time someone told her to respect them, otherwise, they’d pay, Niobe thought it was courageous to ignore them, and have some self-confidence.

But not self-confidence, over the gods, is the ideal. Niobe’s family and beloved ones, were turned into stone, to show the grave consequences disloyalty to the gods might give. So, the gods don’t intend to kill people who disobey them, but make them understand that what they did was purely wrong, and is going to affect them throughout their lives.

Sunday, September 23, 2007

The Centaurs, The Pygmies, and the Griffin

Creatures vs. Humans

In most myths, or Greek Mythology, there are various types and appearances of magical creatures. Myths that prove this are some like The Centaurs, The Pygmies, and The Griffin.

What differs in these, depending on the type of creature it is being talked about, some can be god, or beneficial to humans or gods, or some can despise them and cause harm within the society.

What the myth The Centaurs proves, is that as different as each (humans and creatures) may look, physically, they can be similar in an emotional way. At a party, where the Centaurs were invited, one of them tastes the wine, and felt ill. Hence the Centaur caused battle and hatred within humans, thinking they had intended to kill them.

Yet, there is another story about a much different Centaur, named Chiron. He decided to take a different road, as in the relationships with humans. He was taught, and he thoroughly gained knowledge. Though this part of the story ends “happily”, in a way that Chiron is able to teach humans who’d later be successful, it still proves that creatures—or Centaurs—can be similar to humans, en matter of intelligence and thinking.

Then, the myth of The Pygmies, a culture shows that some creatures might be too distant or occupied to even care about humans having an effect in their culture, that they have other rivals, such as other creatures. In the case of the Pygmies, the Cranes, who’d fight each other over land, cornfields.

Finally, the myth of The Griffin shows that creatures, or some, might respect us as much as we tend to respect them, if we want the same treatment. If the Griffin wants space and freedom, and if they shall have it, no inconveniences with humans might take place.

The challenge here is, that these nests were too tempting for the hunters, and they might have ended up badly for trying to steal the treasures within it.

As different as they may seem, depending on each type of creature, each group might have a different perspective of humans, and gods. They might think the same thing about them, as no matter how superior were god in a way, they still lived and thought similar to humans; they are seeking for power and ownership over something.

Thursday, September 20, 2007

Rhetoric and Issue

http://www.nytimes.com/2007/09/16/opinion/16cross.html?_r=1&n=Top/Opinion/Editorials%20and%20Op-Ed/Op-Ed/Contributors&oref=slogin

The speaker is talking about toy companies such as Mattel and Hasbro, being a bad influence for their customers, which are little kids in the most.

For them to have consumers in the first place, the companies must use one of the types of rhetoric, and it would be ethos. Ethos, because as company workers they are persuading and giving off a good image of what they are selling, and because their working area might affect their character.

It contains, as well, the persuasion of Logos, because once society discovered that Mattel products were painted with leaded paint, it was decided that for the children to not have contact with some sort of lead, all the toys were removed. This would be considered too, to be solved with the issue of choice, for the better future of the children; it is all about making the right decision to have a better performance.

Though the article is not exactly blaming the creators and factories of the physical objects (toys), the speaker is blaming the society and media for affecting the customers of these products in a psychological way. “They serve little positive purpose other than to teach children to be good consumers and want all the Dora the Explorer toys.”


Not only are they convincing them of buying all the “collections” but customers, mostly toddlers are exposed to adults’ daily life, such as money-wasting and the importance of jobs and business-running. It is good to give the kids a representation of what they are up to be living, but a child should have childhood as well.
So therefore, the article is dealing with the issue of blame as well; it talks about a certain thing that happened in the past, or that has been happening from the past, and that it is affecting us today gravely, why we are blaming it in the first place.

Wednesday, September 19, 2007

Alcestis, Antigone, and Penelope

Based on these three myths, we can conlude that women on Ancient Greece were but loyal. Alcestis was the wife of the king of Thessaly, Admetus, and she decided to take the throne when he was about to die. This demonstrates that no matter whether the the law of ruling favour mainly the man than the women, Alcestis was loyal to her husband, and decided to follow her rule after his, like if she were to be taken some legacy he had left he behind.

Then comes Antigone, who was rather loyal to her brother than her greedy uncle. No matter what the uncle, king now instructed, she did what she felt was right, hence her principles and loyalty. Death, was what she obtained by disobeying. But deep inside her she knew she had made the right choice, as she had remained correctly loyal to her brother.

Finally, Penelope, who might be the most solid of all examples. Doing what she was willing. She left her family behind and spent time with her new husband, Odysseus. Then, he had to go to the Trojan Wars leaving Penelope behind for a long period of time. But she was counting on him. Other men came to her house and asked her to marry them, but as patient as she was, she waited, and believed in the return of Odysseus; overall the time, she actually stayed loyal to him, and she didn’t even know whether he was coming back or not-

These women, and their morals and characters, differ variously as from women today. It is true, women have been becoming less loyal each time. But maybe it is because nowadays, so unlike Greece as well, men have been becoming more untrustworthy and women are not sure to trust him always, wherever he comes late, or he looks like he’s hiding something.

Thanks to the influences they received from the environment encircling them, women of the earlier age were in a way more tough, because of the current wars or state of battle with other close civilizations, as well as their lack of safety. There was a period in history when women were much more dependable on man than they are today. Women rights have arose, therefore giving us a valid public opinion, etc.

Monday, September 17, 2007

About the Ancient Poets of Greece (Museaus, Sappho, Simonides)

Superiority (…False)

The writers of today, and their achievements and performance, really depend on themselves. If an author is keen to write to therefore have money, it is probable that their piece of work will be done with much speed, and not enough feelings, that they shall not have fame. Rather, when an author really puts emotion and personality on is/her pieces, it is much likely for him/her to be successful.

Yet meaning they could be wealthy doesn’t necessarily mean they’ll have more privileges than other people, for good. They could pay for the most expensive stuff, in matters such as safety, or danger, they are to be as valuable as the rest on the people on Earth.

What about the writers/poets of the Ancient Greece? In Museaus, we are told in someway indirect that in the EPOCA, writing or poetry could be expressed by anyone, as Museaus was said to be a semi-mythological creature. This somehow connects to the point of Writers having same BENEFITS than others, because the myth is telling than anyone, no matter the type of person or creature, can get to be a writer.

The myth of Sappho ends to the same conclusion; Sappho was a poetess and greatly in love. But with no virtue or characteristic to make her special, she suffered the same fate in the area of love, as most humans would (the person she loved did not loved her back, and she ended up committing suicide).

Then, from the myth Simonides, we can say the same thing as well. It is proven to us that if we are successful, life shall bring good deeds. Simonides did well in his work he was to show the Prince Scopas, and we should believe he deserved the compensation the Prince promised him. It is fair, at the end, for the house to destroy itself un top of the prince and his guests, as he had neglected the price to Simonides.

What I can conclude form these myths, it’s that, no matter in which area we specialize ourselves, for us to do good in life we should always try our best, and for the good of it, try to remember that we are not special nor different from the rest; that the fact that we are whichever culture or sex is going to turn us superior is false.

It is only fair for us to be considered successful when we exceed, when we gain prestige not for who we are, but rather because of what we made.